top of page

Thriftmas Is In. Fake Sales Are Out.

Writer: Madelyn Clarke
Madelyn Clarke
19 hours ago
7 min read

Updated: 12 hours ago

You've probably seen it on TikTok or in the thrift stores themselves. Shoppers are done playing games with holiday "deals", and the way they're gifting this years shows it.


Clothing store window with white mannequins with no clothes to represent no substance, and bold red SALE 70% sign; smaller 30-40% sale boxes below.

Thriftmas and Craftmas are trending this holiday, and this is more than the cute hashtags, this is the market reacting to the economy, and it's a message every brand should be listening to.




Shoppers are buying secondhand, making gifts by hand, and asking harder questions before they spend a dollar.


We get it. Both of our founders, Ashley and myself, are thriftmas-ing and craftmas-ing their way through the holidays this year. And what we have on our wishlists are essentials only, not luxuries. Wants vs. needs is the differentiator this holiday season.



The Red Sticker Lost Its Power


We've all seen the bright red "SALE" stickers. You feel the urgency to buy now and save money with the discount. However, when you check the price history, you see it cost the same as the sale price a month ago when it was not on sale. That's not an accident. A few weeks before a big sale, some retailers raise the regular price, and then announce sales to drive up the urgency.


A consumer watchdog report from Groundwork found that 29% of items in Amazon's Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals were the same price or cheaper in the month before the sale. More than half were the same or cheaper in the 90 days before. (Amazon says it tightened its deal rules for 2026.) In 2025, more than 90 class-action lawsuits were filed against retailers for allegedly using inflated "original" prices to fake a discount.


Not fair? Yep. Legal? Supposedly not.


According to a former deputy director of the FTC's Bureau of Consumer Protection, inflating an "original" price to fake a sale violates the FTC Act. The catch? Enforcement is limited, and cases usually only happen when consumers report them.


So shoppers have started checking for themselves - they need to use price trackers, screenshot prices in October or earlier, compare, and then report. Once someone catches a store faking one sale, they stop believing the rest. When a posts go around social media about it, everyone begins to loose trust in the entire retail industry.



Spreading Out That Holiday Hit


Raise your hand if after 2025 holiday season you said to yourself "I'm going to budget next year's holiday gift shopping throughout the year this time". So did most of the market so welcome to the club!


Deloitte's 2026 Holiday Retail Survey projects that 28% of shoppers' holiday budgets will be spent by the end of October, the highest share in six years. One in four shoppers had already bought holiday items during June promotions.


What used to be a waiting game for the holiday sales to buy every gift doesn't have the same benefit as it did before. People are spreading their spending over an extra month or two so December doesn't hit their bank account all at once. And this year especially a lot of consumers are feeling the economy squeezing the life out of our wallets.


Prices are a big part of it. In a Penny Hoarder survey, 77% of Americans said they're changing how they buy gifts this year because of rising prices and inflation. Circana expects the average holiday spend to drop to $779, down from $796 last year.



Higher Prices, Lower Quality


As prices keep rising, many shoppers are fully aware the quality of what they buy has gone down. Clothing that falls apart after a few washes, electronics that break within months, shoes that barely make it a year...I could go on. Consumers can no longer justify paying high prices, sale or no sale for quality that no longer lives out its valued life.


At the same time, the guardrails are getting thinner. One year after the current administration took control of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, the agency had largely pulled back from enforcement and regulatory work, according to the AP. Consumer advocates say that has cost Americans billions. With less oversight and no more consumer patience for retail pricing games, shoppers are left to protect themselves.


When a dollar buys less, products are lower quality, and discounts can't be trusted, the usual holiday marketing tactics stop working.


It's almost like capitalism cannibalized it's own pride and joy, the holiday shopping season.



Rise of the Intentional Gifts - Thriftmas, Craftmas, and New


Intent and where consumers spend their money is top priority.


Instead of buying more, shoppers are buying more carefully. Before they buy a gift, many are asking three questions:

  • Will they use this more than once?

  • Will this actually make their life better?

  • Or will it sit in a closet and take up space?


These questions are applied to new, used, and handmade gift options this holiday season.


ThredUp's 2026 Holiday Resale Report found that 62% of U.S. consumers plan to buy secondhand this season, putting an average of 37% of their gift budget toward it. Thirty percent say secondhand helps them buy for more people, up from 23% last year. And CivicScience found the share of people who are "very likely" to give a secondhand gift has more than doubled since 2022, from 8% to 17%.


Handmade, either by self or a local vendor are also increasingly popular this year. We saw it first hand at our client The Clyde Artist Network's 6th Annual Arts and Crafts Holiday Festival. "I got most of my holiday shopping done today!" and "I'd rather spend money at a local vendor than a big chain this year" were very popular sentiments from attendees, and staff.


Personally, I will be making candle sets for each of my loved ones.



The Generational Drivers


This shift is being led by younger shoppers, who now make up a larger share of holiday spending as they come into higher levels of purchasing power.


For the first time, Gen Z and millennials are expected to account for half of all holiday spending, according to Deloitte. They also shop differently. This year, 33% of Gen Z and 29% of millennials plan to buy personalized or monogrammed gifts, compared with 14% of Gen X and just 5% of baby boomers.


One of the first segmentation lessons I learned in college was that millennials (me included) prefer experiences rather than material purchases.


A Harris poll for Eventbrite found that 78% of millennials would rather spend money on an experience than on a thing. Only 56% of boomers felt the same way.


The unwanted-gift numbers point the same way. Gen Z receives far and away more unwanted gifts than any other generation, with 74% saying they've received a gift they didn't want. Millennials follow at 67%, then Gen X at 48%, according to a Finder survey. Finder's UK survey shows the same pattern: 74% of millennials have been given an unwanted Christmas present, compared with 35% of boomers.


Most of us have opened these gifts, they're often gifts to make the pile look bigger, and most get used once and thrown away.


Living space plays a huge part in this shift as well. Millennials are buying homes later than any generation on record. The median age of a first-time homebuyer hit 40 in 2025, up from 33 in 2021 and 28 in 1991, according to the National Association of Realtors. For someone renting a smaller place well into their 30s, a gift that takes up space and doesn't get used is a real cost. Meanwhile, boomers are significantly more likely than millennials and Gen X to say their household never lives simply or minimally, according to a Mayflower survey.


This explains why younger shoppers ask whether a gift will take up space before they buy it. For brands, it means the people doing more of the buying are judging products by whether they will actually get used.



Why Urgency Marketing Is Losing Its Effect


For years, holiday marketing ran on one 'secret': create urgency, slap on a discount, and people will buy. Limited time! Doorbusters! Ends at midnight! Trick or Treat?


That only works when people trust the deal. It doesn't work when people's patience is at an all time low.


Consumers know most of the sales are fake, they know their dollar doesn't stretch like it used to, and they know the quality is going down the drain.


Urgency without honesty just looks like another trick and doesn't feel authentic. Frankly, it's out of touch for millions of Americans this year.


The brands that win this season will be the ones people believe and trust the most, not the ones with the biggest, loudest sale signs.



What This Means for Your Brand


If you sell to consumers this holiday season, these are the five places we would start.


1. Make your prices honest. If a product isn't really discounted, don't label it as a sale. Showing price history or offering a holiday price guarantee gives shoppers a way to check your claim, and a shopper who can check it is more likely to buy from you again.


2. Show the experience behind the gift. Shoppers are asking whether a gift will get used. Answer that in your marketing by showing the product in everyday use months after it's bought, not only when it comes out of the box.


3. Lead with quality and proof. Explain what the product is made of, how long it lasts, and what your warranty covers, and back it up with real customer reviews. With negative reviews, address responsively with accountability and respect. When shoppers feel quality has dropped across the market, an accountable brand that holds up will stand out.


4. Plan for a longer season. Holiday spending now runs from October into January. A plan built entirely around Black Friday misses the shoppers who started early and the ones still buying after the holidays.


5. Keep your pricing consistent across channels. Your ads, website, emails, and in-store signs should show the same prices and the same offers. A shopper who sees one price in an ad and another on your site has a reason to doubt both.



In the Spirit of the Holidays, Build Back Trust Now...AND For The 2027 Holiday Season.


Thriftmas and Craftmas aren't anti-spending, what they really are is anti-nonsense signals. People still want to give great gifts. They just want to feel good about where their money went.


That's a strategy problem based on the lack of psychographic segmentation, not a discount problem. And it's exactly the kind of problem we love to solve.


Want to make sure if your holiday marketing is earning trust or burning it? Let's talk.


Sign up for our newsletter for more Marketing Strategy Insights.



Share your thoughts and comment below! Are you thrifting, crafting or intentional shopping this holiday season?






References

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page